All Inclusive vs A La Carte: What Really Saves You Money

When you choose between an all inclusive, a vacation package where meals, drinks, and often activities are bundled into one upfront price. Also known as all-inclusive resort, it promises simplicity—no counting coins at dinner, no surprise bills at checkout. But does it actually save you money? Or are you paying extra for convenience you don’t even use? The truth is, all inclusive isn’t always the bargain it looks like. Many guests end up spending more because they’re stuck with bland food, overpriced drinks they don’t like, and activities they don’t care about—all while missing out on local flavors and real experiences nearby.

On the other side, a la carte, paying for each meal, drink, or service separately. Also known as pay-as-you-go vacation, it gives you control. Want fresh seafood from a beachside shack? Go for it. Craving a local craft beer instead of the resort’s generic lager? You can get it. No one’s forcing you into a 3-hour buffet line or limiting you to six drinks a day. But here’s the catch: a la carte demands planning. You need to research prices, track spending, and sometimes wait in lines. It’s not as lazy, but it’s often more authentic—and cheaper—if you know where to go. The real difference isn’t just price—it’s freedom. All inclusive packages often lock you into one resort, one menu, one vibe. A la carte lets you explore, wander, and discover what the place is really like beyond the resort gates.

And let’s talk about the hidden stuff. Resorts love to say "unlimited drinks"—but how many are you really allowed? Some cap it at six a day. Others charge extra for premium brands. Tipping? It’s not required, but staff depend on it. Skip it, and you’re hurting people who work hard for little pay. Meanwhile, with a la carte, you decide exactly how much to spend—and where. Want to splurge on one amazing dinner? Do it. Skip breakfast and grab coffee from a local shop? Totally fine. You’re not locked in.

Then there’s the location factor. All inclusive resorts are often built far from towns, so you’re stuck unless you pay for a taxi. A la carte lets you stay in a cozy cottage near the village, walk to markets, chat with locals, and eat where the people do. That’s not just cheaper—it’s richer. And if you’re traveling with kids, teens, or a partner who wants more than poolside lounging, a la carte gives you the flexibility to do different things every day.

So which is better? It depends on what you want. If you’re looking for zero planning, total relaxation, and don’t mind the same menu every night, all inclusive might work. But if you care about real food, local culture, value, and freedom? A la carte wins. Most people don’t realize how much they’re giving up just to avoid thinking about their vacation. The best trips aren’t the ones with the most included— they’re the ones where you get to choose what matters most to you.

Below, you’ll find real stories from travelers who’ve tried both. Some saved thousands. Others lost money without even knowing why. No theory. No marketing. Just what actually happened.